For most woodworking projects, I’d start with the DEWALT DW788, which stands out as the best overall pick for its 20-inch capacity and variable-speed control. The Dremel Moto-Saw is a compact alternative for light-duty work and easy storage, while the Shop Fox W1872 offers extra versatility with a foot switch and rotary shaft. The main tradeoffs are cutting capacity, blade-change convenience, work-area visibility, and how much bench space a saw takes up. A larger throat can handle broader pieces, but it does not automatically mean cleaner or more accurate cuts. Read on for my comparison of all 15 woodworking scroll saws and guidance on choosing one for your projects.
Get business pricing on tools and workshop supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The DEWALT DW788 leads for all-around capacity: its 20-inch throat gives more room for wider work than the many 16-inch models in this group.
- Compactness changes the job the saw can do: the Dremel Moto-Saw favors light projects and easier storage, not the broad work capacity of a full-size bench saw.
- Blade access is a practical differentiator: the WEN 3922 and the WEN model with easy-access blade changes address a frequent interruption when cutting internal shapes.
- Visibility and control features vary across the 16-inch options: LED lights, work lights, and variable-speed controls can make detailed work easier, but buyers should compare these with blade access and table setup.
- More throat capacity adds reach, not automatic precision: the 18- and 22-inch BUCKTOOL models suit larger workpieces, while careful blade choice, setup, and feed control still determine cut quality.
| woodworking scroll saw | Weight | Power source |
|---|---|---|
| Dewalt Scroll Saw | 56 pounds | — |
| Dremel Moto-Saw MS20-01 Variab | 4.12 kg | Corded electric |
| Garvee 16" Variable Speed Scro | 25.2 pounds | Corded electric |
| WEN 16-Inch Variable Speed Scr | 25.5 pounds | — |
| RYOBI 1.2 AMP Corded 16 in. Sc | 27 pounds | — |
| BUCKTOOL 18-Inch Scroll Saw | — | Corded electric |
| BUCKTOOL 16-Inch Scroll Saw | — | — |
| Garvee 16" Variable Speed Scro | 26.8 pounds | Corded electric |
| DeWalt 18-Inch Scroll Saw with | 34.2 pounds | 120 V corded electric |
| WEN 3922 16-inch Variable Spee | 24.9 pounds | — |
| WEN 16-Inch Variable Speed Scr | 11.5 kg | Corded electric |
| SKIL 1.2 Amp 16 in. Variable S | 24.7 pounds | Corded electric |
| BUCKTOOL 22-Inch Scroll Saw | — | Corded electric, 120 volts |
| Shop Fox W1872 16" Variable Sp | 26 pounds | AC, 120 volts |
| 16-Inch Adjustable Speed Scrol | 26 pounds | Corded electric |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Dewalt Scroll Saw, 1.3 Amp, 20 in Steel Blade, Variable-Speed Trigger (DW788)
The DeWalt DW788 is the strongest fit here for woodworkers who put controlled, detailed cuts ahead of portability. Its 20-inch capacity gives it more room for larger patterns than the 16-inch WEN and RYOBI models, while the variable speed range of 400 to 1,750 SPM helps match cutting pace to the material and detail. The cast-iron table and reduced-vibration design support steadier work on intricate shapes, and tool-free blade changes make inside cuts less tedious. That capability comes with a real tradeoff: at 56 pounds, it is much less convenient to move or store than the compact Dremel Moto-Saw. Choose it for a dedicated workshop rather than a portable setup; buyers who mainly cut small craft pieces may not need its larger capacity.
Pros:- 20-inch capacity accommodates larger patterns than the 16-inch models in this group.
- Variable speed from 400 to 1,750 SPM offers control across different cuts.
- Cast-iron table and reduced vibration support steadier detail work.
- Tool-free blade changes simplify interior cuts.
Cons:- At 56 pounds, it is difficult to move or store between projects.
- The 20-inch capacity may be unnecessary for small craft work.
Best for: Woodworkers with a dedicated bench who regularly cut detailed patterns or larger workpieces and value low vibration and a 20-inch throat.
Not ideal for: Portable-tool buyers or occasional crafters who need a light saw for small projects; its 56-pound weight and larger capacity are more than they need.
- Motor:1.3 amp
- Blade capacity:20 inches
- Speed range:400–1,750 SPM
- Blade stroke:3/4–2 inches
- Table:Cast iron; bevels 45° left and right
- Weight:56 pounds
Our verdict“Choose the DW788 for a stationary woodworking setup where precision, reduced vibration, and extra cutting capacity matter more than portability.”
Dremel Moto-Saw MS20-01 Variable Speed Compact Scroll Saw Kit
The Dremel Moto-Saw MS20-01 is the lineup’s portability specialist, not a like-for-like substitute for a full-size bench saw. Its compact body can be set up for scroll-saw work, then detached for handheld coping cuts, giving small-shop users options the DeWalt DW788 does not. Quick blade changes and auto-tensioning are useful when switching between small projects or materials such as wood, plastic, and laminates. The tradeoff is capacity: its short 3.8-inch blade and compact format are better suited to modest pieces than broad woodworking blanks, unlike the 16-inch WEN or 20-inch DeWalt. The supplied data also flags that some users find the tensioning mechanism challenging. I’d choose it for a portable craft station, but skip it as a primary saw for larger, frequent woodworking projects.
Pros:- Compact design is easier to store and transport than the full-size DeWalt or WEN saws.
- Detachable body supports handheld coping cuts as well as mounted scroll-saw work.
- Auto-tensioning and quick blade changes can speed up small project changes.
- Designed for cutting wood, plastic, laminates, and metal.
Cons:- Its 3.8-inch blade and compact format are less suited to larger woodworking pieces.
- Some users may find the blade-tensioning mechanism difficult to adjust.
- The listed 120-volt supply may not suit buyers in regions using different mains voltage.
Best for: Apartment-based makers, craft users, and woodworkers who need a stowable saw for small pieces and occasional handheld coping cuts.
Not ideal for: Woodworkers cutting large panels or relying on a full-size bench saw for frequent, long sessions; its compact blade and format limit the work it suits.
- Power source:Corded electric
- Voltage:120 volts
- Wattage:120 watts
- Blade length:3.8 inches
- Cutting angle:90 degrees
- Dimensions:9.84 × 8.5 × 10.6 inches
- Weight:4.12 kg
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Pick the Moto-Saw for portable, small-scale craft cutting and handheld flexibility, not for replacing a full-size woodworking scroll saw.”
Garvee 16″ Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Tilting Worktable and Dust Port
The Garvee 16-inch scroll saw earns its place for hobbyists who want a tilting table and variable speed without moving up to the heavier, larger-capacity DeWalt DW788. Its 0–45° table tilt supports bevel work, while the 500–1,600 SPM range gives users room to adjust cutting pace for wood, acrylic, and other materials. At 25.2 pounds, it is also easier to reposition than the 56-pound DeWalt, though it remains a bench-style tool rather than a truly portable option like the Dremel Moto-Saw. The 16-inch capacity sets a clear limit on workpiece size, and the dust port needs an external vacuum to collect debris. Its feature set is aimed at home projects, so buyers seeking professional-level capacity or more advanced adjustments should look elsewhere.
Pros:- Tilting table adjusts from 0° to 45° for bevel cuts.
- Variable speed from 500 to 1,600 SPM helps adapt cutting pace to the project.
- At 25.2 pounds, it is lighter than the DeWalt DW788.
- Dust port provides a connection point for external extraction.
Cons:- The 16-inch capacity limits the size of workpieces it can handle.
- Dust collection requires an external vacuum.
- Its basic feature set may not meet professional users’ needs.
Best for: DIY woodworkers and craft hobbyists who want to make bevel cuts on modest-sized projects and can connect a shop vacuum to the dust port.
Not ideal for: Professional users needing larger workpiece capacity or advanced controls, and buyers who expect the dust port to collect debris without a separate vacuum.
- Model:SBS-16D
- Capacity:16 inches
- Speed range:500–1,600 SPM
- Table tilt:0–45°
- Power source:Corded electric
- Blade material:Stainless steel
- Dimensions:24.02 × 12.6 × 9.84 inches
- Weight:25.2 pounds
Our verdict“Choose the Garvee for home projects that call for bevel cuts and adjustable speed, provided a 16-inch capacity and external dust extraction suit your setup.”
WEN 16-Inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Work Light
The WEN 16-inch scroll saw is a practical middle ground for hobbyists who want useful bench features without the DeWalt DW788’s 20-inch footprint and weight. Its speed adjusts from 400 to 1,600 SPM, and the blade accepts two directions, which adds flexibility for different cuts. A built-in work light helps illuminate fine lines, while the dust port and onboard storage make the workstation more organized. Compared with the Garvee 16-inch, the WEN adds that work light and blade orientation option; both remain limited to 16-inch workpieces. The cast-iron base helps reduce vibration, but the saw is specified for wood up to 2 inches thick, and setup may take patience. It suits detail-focused home projects better than thick stock or buyers looking for cordless convenience.
Pros:- Variable speed from 400 to 1,600 SPM covers a broad range of cutting tasks.
- Blade can be installed in two directions for added cutting flexibility.
- Work light improves visibility around detailed cut lines.
- Cast-iron base helps reduce vibration; dust port and onboard storage add workshop convenience.
Cons:- Specified for wood cutting up to 2 inches thick.
- The 16-inch capacity is smaller than the DeWalt DW788’s 20-inch capacity.
- Setup may feel complex for buyers seeking a quick-start tool.
Best for: Hobbyist woodworkers who cut intricate patterns on modest-sized pieces and value a work light, onboard storage, and alternate blade orientation.
Not ideal for: Users who regularly cut wood thicker than 2 inches, need more than 16 inches of capacity, or require a cordless saw.
- Capacity:16 inches
- Speed range:400–1,600 SPM
- Wattage:144 watts
- Voltage:120 volts
- Maximum wood thickness:2 inches
- Cutting angle:Up to 45°
- Dimensions:26.38 × 13 × 14.75 inches
- Weight:25.5 pounds
Our verdict“Pick the WEN for illuminated, flexible detail work on smaller wood pieces, but choose the DeWalt if you need greater capacity.”
RYOBI 1.2 AMP Corded 16 in. Scroll Saw SC165VS
The RYOBI SC165VS is a straightforward 16-inch choice for woodworkers who want easy blade changes and a built-in way to clear dust from the cut line. Its tool-free blade changes reduce the friction of interior cuts, while the integrated dust blower helps keep the work area visible without requiring a vacuum connection. Compared with the WEN 16-inch, the RYOBI emphasizes simpler blade handling and a blower; the WEN offers a work light and two-direction blade acceptance instead. Both are smaller-capacity alternatives to the 20-inch DeWalt DW788. The RYOBI’s 1.2-amp motor and basic adjustment set make it a sensible fit for routine hobby work, not a feature-rich upgrade. Its listed 30-day warranty is also notably short, and its 27-pound weight makes it less convenient to carry than the Dremel.
Pros:- Tool-free blade changes simplify blade replacement and interior cuts.
- Integrated dust blower helps clear debris from the cutting area.
- 1.2-amp motor is suited to routine woodworking projects.
- 45° cutting angle supports angled work.
Cons:- The listed 30-day warranty is short compared with the Dremel Moto-Saw’s two-year warranty.
- Its 16-inch capacity is less than the DeWalt DW788’s 20-inch capacity.
- Basic adjustment features may limit buyers seeking more control.
Best for: Home woodworkers doing routine scroll-saw projects who prioritize tool-free blade changes and an integrated dust blower over advanced adjustments.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a long warranty, extensive adjustment features, larger workpiece capacity, or a lightweight saw for frequent transport.
- Motor:1.2 amp
- Capacity:16 inches
- Voltage:120 volts
- Wattage:144 watts
- Cutting angle:45°
- Dimensions:26.57 × 12.99 × 15.15 inches
- Weight:27 pounds
- Warranty:30 days
Our verdict“Choose the RYOBI for routine 16-inch woodworking projects when convenient blade changes and a dust blower matter more than advanced features or warranty length.”
BUCKTOOL 18-Inch Scroll Saw, 1.3A Power Scroll Saw for Woodworking
The BUCKTOOL 18-inch makes the most sense when your patterns or workpieces need more throat room than a 16-inch saw provides. Its 550–1600 FPM variable speed gives you room to slow down for controlled detail work or speed up for less delicate cuts, while the rotating arm supports angled cutting without relying only on tilting the table. The 21-by-13-inch worktable is also more generous than the WEN 3922’s 16-by-10-inch table, which can help support wider stock as you turn it. The tradeoff is a corded, less portable setup, and the listed dimensions appear unusually small for an 18-inch saw, so I’d verify the machine’s actual footprint before planning a bench. Choose it over the BUCKTOOL 16-inch when capacity matters more than compactness.
Pros:- 18-inch capacity offers more room for larger workpieces than the 16-inch options in this lineup.
- Variable speed from 550 to 1600 FPM supports different materials and levels of cutting detail.
- Rotating arm allows angled cuts while keeping the workpiece position more consistent.
- Tool-less blade changes and a large 21-by-13-inch table support practical project setup.
Cons:- Corded power limits where the saw can be used.
- The listed dimensions are unusually small for this class, so buyers should confirm the actual footprint.
- Its size and weight may make it inconvenient to move between work areas.
Best for: Woodworkers cutting larger panels or patterns who want an 18-inch throat and a roomy work surface for detailed projects.
Not ideal for: Small-shop users who need a portable saw or have limited bench space; its corded design and reported weight make frequent moving less convenient.
- Motor:1.3 A; 156 W
- Throat capacity:18 inches
- Blade speed:550–1600 FPM
- Worktable:21 x 13 inches
- Cutting angle:45 degrees
- Power source:Corded electric
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Choose this BUCKTOOL over the 16-inch models when larger workpieces and a generous table matter more than portability.”
BUCKTOOL 16-Inch Scroll Saw, 1.3A Power Scroll Saw for Woodworking
This BUCKTOOL 16-inch stands out for combining a pivoting saw arm with variable speed, making it a distinct choice for makers who want to change cutting angles without treating table tilt as the only approach. Its 19-11/16-by-13-3/8-inch table is notably broad for a 16-inch saw, giving larger pieces more support than the WEN 3922’s 16-by-10-inch surface. The tool-less blade change system also suits projects with frequent interior cuts, where blade removal and reinstallation can become part of the workflow. Compared with the 18-inch BUCKTOOL, this model gives up throat capacity, and its listed speed range uses RPM rather than the FPM figures supplied for that larger model, so the numbers are not directly comparable. The manufacturer also notes possible vibration at higher speeds.
Pros:- Pivoting arm supports angled cutting and offers an alternative to table-only adjustments.
- Broad 19-11/16-by-13-3/8-inch worktable provides substantial support for a 16-inch saw.
- Variable speed helps adapt the cut to different materials and detail levels.
- Tool-less blade changes and integrated dust collection support repeat project work.
Cons:- 16-inch capacity is less suitable for oversized patterns than the 18-inch BUCKTOOL.
- Potential vibration at higher speeds may affect control on delicate cuts.
- Corded operation restricts placement to areas with a suitable outlet.
Best for: Hobbyist woodworkers who mainly cut workpieces within a 16-inch throat and value a broad table and pivoting-arm angle adjustments.
Not ideal for: Buyers who regularly cut wide patterns beyond 16 inches or need especially smooth operation at the highest speeds.
- Motor:1.3 A; 156 W
- Throat capacity:16 inches
- Speed range:360–1550 RPM
- Worktable:19-11/16 x 13-3/8 inches
- Cutting angle:45 degrees
- Dust collection:Integrated system
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Pick this model over the WEN 3922 if a wide worktable and pivoting-arm angle cuts matter more than larger throat capacity.”
Garvee 16″ Variable Speed Scroll Saw with LED Light and Dust Port
The Garvee is a straightforward option for hobbyists who want table tilt up to 45 degrees and adjustable speed without stepping up to an 18-inch saw. Its 500–1600 SPM range covers slower, more controlled work as well as quicker cuts, while the dust port offers a way to connect extraction and keep the immediate work area clearer. At 26.8 pounds, it is lighter than the 34.2-pound DeWalt 18-inch, though neither is a grab-and-go tool. Compared with the WEN 3922, the Garvee’s listed specs emphasize bevel cutting and a dust port, while the WEN supplies a cast iron base and side-panel blade access. This is a simpler feature set, and its 16-inch capacity rules out some larger patterns. Buyers should also note that the supplied warranty information is a 30-day Amazon return guarantee, not a longer manufacturer warranty.
Pros:- 500–1600 SPM speed adjustment suits varied cutting pace and detail work.
- Tilting worktable supports bevel cuts up to 45 degrees.
- Dust port provides a connection point for workspace dust management.
- At 26.8 pounds, it is lighter than the 18-inch DeWalt listed here.
Cons:- 16-inch cutting capacity limits the size of patterns and stock it can handle.
- Feature set is more basic than the WEN 3922, which lists a cast iron base and side-panel blade access.
- Warranty information provided is limited to Amazon’s 30-day return guarantee.
Best for: DIY woodworkers cutting small-to-medium projects who want a tilting table, variable speed, and a dust port in a 16-inch saw.
Not ideal for: Frequent production users who need a longer stated manufacturer warranty, advanced controls, or capacity for oversized workpieces.
- Throat capacity:16 inches
- Speed range:500–1600 SPM
- Worktable tilt:0–45 degrees
- Weight:26.8 pounds
- Dimensions:24.02 x 12.6 x 9.84 inches
- Power source:Corded electric
- Dust management:Dust port
- Warranty information:Amazon.com 30-Day Return Guarantee
Our verdict“Choose the Garvee for occasional 16-inch projects where bevel capability and a dust port take priority over advanced features or a longer listed warranty.”
DeWalt 18-Inch Scroll Saw with 1.6 AMP Motor and Variable Speed
Among the listed options, this DeWalt pairs an 18-inch throat with a die-cast aluminum table, making it a strong fit for woodworkers who want room for larger designs and a substantial working platform. The 1.6-amp motor is higher-rated than the 1.3-amp BUCKTOOL 18-inch, and the front-facing bevel scale and oversized controls are designed to make adjustments easier to reach. Its 34.2-pound weight can help keep a bench setup planted, but it is a clear drawback if the saw needs to be moved often. The supplied description gives a variable range of 500–1500 strokes per minute, while the spec list states 1500 feet per minute; that unit mismatch makes the speed listing difficult to interpret. Compared with the WEN 3922, it offers more throat capacity but takes up more space.
Pros:- 18-inch throat accommodates larger patterns than the 16-inch WEN 3922.
- Die-cast aluminum table is intended to provide a stable cutting surface and reduce vibration.
- Front bevel scale and oversized controls make angle adjustments easier to access.
- Three-year limited warranty is longer than the two-year warranties listed for the BUCKTOOL models.
Cons:- At 34.2 pounds, it is cumbersome to move frequently.
- Corded power limits placement to locations with an electrical outlet.
- The supplied speed figures use conflicting units, making the operating range unclear.
Best for: Woodworkers with a dedicated bench who cut larger projects and value a stable table, accessible controls, and a three-year limited warranty.
Not ideal for: Casual makers with little storage space or anyone needing a lightweight, portable scroll saw.
- Motor:1.6 A
- Throat capacity:18 inches
- Stated variable speed:500–1500 strokes per minute
- Table material:Die-cast aluminum
- Cutting angle:45 degrees
- Weight:34.2 pounds
- Power source:120 V corded electric
- Warranty:3-year limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose this DeWalt for a permanent workshop setup with larger projects, but favor a lighter 16-inch model if portability or space is a priority.”
WEN 3922 16-inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Easy-Access Blade Changes
The WEN 3922 earns its place through a workflow feature that matters on intricate projects: side-panel access and a tool-free blade holder make blade changes easier to reach, particularly when a pattern calls for repeated interior cuts. Its 550–1600 SPM variable speed and table bevel up to 45 degrees cover the core needs of many woodworking projects. A cast iron base adds stability, setting it apart from the Garvee’s more basic feature set, though the WEN’s 16-by-10-inch table is smaller than the BUCKTOOL 16-inch’s listed surface. The WEN is also a corded 24.9-pound machine, so it is not a portable bench tool. The supplied data lists a 15-volt supply and a 225-watt rating; buyers should confirm electrical requirements before purchase because that voltage figure may need clarification.
Pros:- Side-panel access and a tool-free blade holder simplify repeated blade changes.
- Variable speed from 550 to 1600 SPM supports controlled cutting across project types.
- Cast iron base is intended to reduce vibration during operation.
- Bevels up to 45 degrees for angled cuts.
Cons:- The 16-by-10-inch table is smaller than the BUCKTOOL 16-inch model’s listed table.
- At 24.9 pounds and corded, it is not convenient for frequent relocation.
- The supplied 15-volt specification should be verified before purchase.
Best for: Woodworkers who make frequent interior cuts and want convenient blade access, variable speed, and a stable base in a 16-inch saw.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a large worktable, cordless portability, or unambiguous electrical specifications without checking the product details first.
- Throat capacity:16 inches
- Worktable:16 x 10 inches
- Speed range:550–1600 SPM
- Table bevel:Up to 45 degrees
- Base:Cast iron
- Weight:24.9 pounds
- Wattage:225 W
- Listed voltage:15 V
Our verdict“Choose the WEN 3922 if frequent interior cuts make easy blade access a priority and its smaller table suits your projects.”
WEN 16-Inch Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Work Light and Easy Access Blade Changes
I’d shortlist this WEN for projects that involve frequent interior cuts, where blade changes can interrupt the work. Its side-access panel makes those changes easier to reach than on a more basic setup, while the 550–1,600 SPM range gives room to slow down for delicate turns or speed up on straightforward cuts. The work light and dust port also help with visibility and debris control. Compared with the SKIL 16-inch scroll saw, this model’s listed details emphasize accessible blade changes and a dust port, while SKIL adds keyless blade changes and on-tool storage. The WEN’s 45-degree bevel suits angled work, but its 2-inch maximum cutting thickness and corded power limit what and where I’d use it. At 11.5 kg, it is not an especially portable bench tool.
Pros:- Side panel provides convenient access for blade changes
- Variable speed from 550 to 1,600 SPM supports control across different cuts
- Work light and dust port help with visibility and workspace cleanup
- Table bevels up to 45 degrees for angled cuts
Cons:- 11.5 kg weight makes it less convenient to carry or store between uses
- Maximum cutting thickness is limited to 2 inches
- Corded power restricts placement to areas near an outlet
Best for: Woodworkers making fretwork or other projects with frequent interior cuts who want a side-access blade panel, variable speed, and built-in task lighting.
Not ideal for: Makers who need to move their saw between work areas or cut stock thicker than the listed 2-inch capacity.
- Power source:Corded electric
- Blade length:16 inches
- Table size:16.25 x 10 inches
- Maximum cutting thickness:2 inches
- Bevel range:Up to 45 degrees
- Stroke speed:550–1,600 strokes per minute
- Weight:11.5 kg
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Choose this WEN if accessible blade changes matter more to your interior-cut workflow than portability or extra cutting thickness.”
SKIL 1.2 Amp 16 in. Variable Speed Scroll Saw with LED Work Light for Woodworking
I’d favor the SKIL when keeping blades close at hand is part of a tidy, repeatable setup. Its keyless blade-change system reduces the need to reach for a separate key, and on-tool blade storage helps keep spare blades with the saw. That gives it a practical edge over the WEN 16-inch with side-access changes, whose listed strengths focus on panel access, a dust port, and an included work light. SKIL counters with an integrated LED light, variable speed, and a table that tilts for angled cuts. Its 16-inch blade format and corded power suit a fixed hobby bench, but the 24.7-pound weight is a drawback if the saw needs to be moved often. The supplied specifications do not state a speed range or cutting thickness, so buyers seeking those figures should compare carefully.
Pros:- Keyless system makes blade changes more convenient
- On-tool storage keeps spare blades near the work area
- Integrated LED light illuminates detailed cuts
- Tilting table supports angled work up to 45 degrees
Cons:- At 24.7 pounds, it is less convenient to move than a lighter bench saw
- Corded design limits placement and use away from outlets
- Provided product data does not specify cutting thickness or stroke-speed range
Best for: Hobby woodworkers who want keyless blade changes and built-in blade storage for a dedicated, organized scroll-saw station.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a highly portable saw or want a clearly stated cutting-thickness capacity and speed range before choosing.
- Power source:Corded electric
- Voltage:120 volts
- Wattage:144 watts
- Blade length:16 inches
- Cutting angle:Up to 45 degrees
- Weight:24.7 pounds
- Blade material:High-speed steel
- Warranty:3-year limited warranty
Our verdict“Pick the SKIL for an organized bench setup where keyless blade changes and on-tool storage matter more than portability.”
BUCKTOOL 22-Inch Scroll Saw, 1/5 HP 1.3A Power Scroll Saws for Woodworking
The BUCKTOOL earns its place for woodworkers who need room to maneuver larger workpieces, not simply another 16-inch saw. Its 27 x 13-inch table offers a broader support area than the Shop Fox W1872’s 16-inch maximum cut width, which can make handling larger panels or awkward shapes less cramped. The listed 22-inch capacity and variable speed from 360 to 1,550 add flexibility, while the raised, lockable arm is designed to simplify blade replacement and interior cuts. Its beveling arm tilts 30 degrees left and 45 degrees right, giving it a different angle range from models with a single-direction tilt. The tradeoff is a larger working footprint, and the supplied product data does not list the saw’s weight or warranty. Buyers should also confirm that its blade compatibility matches their preferred stock.
Pros:- 22-inch capacity and 27 x 13-inch table provide room for larger work
- Variable speed range of 360–1,550 supports a range of cutting tasks
- Lockable raised arm is designed to ease blade changes and interior cuts
- Bevels 30 degrees left and 45 degrees right
Cons:- Large table and 22-inch capacity call for more bench space than 16-inch models
- Supplied product data does not specify item weight
- Supplied product data does not state a warranty duration
Best for: Woodworkers handling larger panels or shapes who want a roomy table, extended throat capacity, and a liftable arm for interior cuts.
Not ideal for: Makers with limited bench space or buyers who need a confirmed weight and warranty specification before selecting a saw.
- Capacity:22 inches
- Motor:1/5 HP, 1.3 A
- Speed:360–1,550 RPM (as listed)
- Worktable:27 x 13 inches
- Bevel range:30 degrees left and 45 degrees right
- Blade compatibility:5-inch pinless blades; listed compatibility with 10, 20, 25, 43, and 47 TPI blades
- Dust management:Adjustable dust blower and 1-1/2-inch dust port
- Power source:Corded electric, 120 volts
Our verdict“Choose the BUCKTOOL if larger workpieces and a spacious table are your priority and you have room for a full-size saw.”
Shop Fox W1872 16″ Variable Speed Scroll Saw with Foot Switch, LED Light, Miter Gauge, Rotary Shaft
The Shop Fox W1872 is the most accessory-focused pick here. Its foot switch lets the operator control the motor without moving a hand from the work, while the included miter gauge and flexible rotary shaft extend its usefulness beyond straightforward scroll cuts. That makes it a more involved setup than the WEN 16-inch model, whose listed package centers on a work light, dust port, and side-access blade changes. The Shop Fox also offers variable speed from 550 to 1,600 SPM and a table tilt from -5 to 45 degrees, with a stated 2-1/4-inch maximum cutting thickness. The additional features come with extra bulk: at 26 pounds, it is less appealing for a frequently moved bench tool. Buyers should also verify the listed wattage against their power requirements.
Pros:- Foot switch allows motor control without taking a hand off the work
- Miter gauge and flexible rotary shaft add uses beyond basic scroll cutting
- Variable speed from 550 to 1,600 SPM accommodates different cutting tasks
- Listed maximum cutting thickness is 2-1/4 inches
Cons:- 26-pound weight makes moving and storing the saw less convenient
- Maximum cutting width is limited to 16 inches
- Listed wattage is unusually high relative to the stated 1/6 HP motor, so buyers may want to verify the electrical specification
Best for: Woodworkers who want foot-operated motor control and accessories such as a miter gauge and rotary shaft for varied detail work.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a lightweight, simple scroll saw or a tool with a cutting width beyond the listed 16-inch capacity.
- Motor power:1/6 HP
- Power source:AC, 120 volts
- Blade speed:550–1,600 SPM
- Maximum cutting thickness:2-1/4 inches
- Maximum cutting width:16 inches
- Table tilt:-5 to 45 degrees
- Blade stroke:9/16 inch
- Weight:26 pounds
Our verdict“Choose the Shop Fox if foot control and its included accessories are useful to your workflow, and you can keep the heavier saw at a fixed bench.”
16-Inch Adjustable Speed Scroll Saw with Tilting Work Table and LED Light
This 16-inch saw stands out for a 400 SPM low-speed setting, which gives detail-focused woodworkers more room to work slowly than the WEN and Shop Fox models, both of which start at 550 SPM. That broader listed range can be useful when following tight patterns or working with materials such as acrylic, which the product data names alongside wood and crafts. Its 45-degree tilting table, built-in LED, blade guard, and hold-down shoe cover the basics for controlled bench work. Compared with the SKIL 16-inch saw, this model specifies its speed range and safety features, while SKIL lists keyless blade changes and on-tool blade storage. The tradeoff is a 26-pound weight, corded power, and no included stand or storage options; the supplied details also omit table dimensions and warranty information.
Pros:- 400–1,600 SPM range offers a slower starting speed than the listed WEN and Shop Fox models
- Tilting table adjusts from 0 to 45 degrees
- LED light, blade guard, and hold-down shoe support visibility and workpiece control
- Product data lists wood, acrylic, and crafts as suitable surfaces
Cons:- At 26 pounds, it is not a convenient choice for frequent relocation
- Corded power limits where it can be used
- No stand or storage options are listed, and table dimensions are not provided
Best for: Detail-oriented makers who want a low starting speed for intricate cuts in wood, acrylic, or craft materials at a fixed workbench.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a portable saw, included stand, or more complete published specifications such as table size and warranty.
- Power source:Corded electric
- Blade speed:400–1,600 strokes per minute
- Motor:0.9 A
- Worktable tilt:0–45 degrees
- Weight:26 pounds
- Blade material:Stainless steel
- Listed work materials:Wood, acrylic, and crafts
Our verdict“Pick this saw for slower-speed detail work across listed craft materials if you can supply a stable bench and do not need included storage.”
How We Picked
I compared these woodworking scroll saws on the factors that change day-to-day use: cutting capacity, speed control, blade-change access, work-area visibility, table adjustment, and practical extras such as dust ports or foot switches. I also considered the different jobs each design suits, from small craft work and occasional home projects to larger panels and more involved shop use. A feature matters here only when it gives a buyer a useful advantage, such as improved access for interior cuts or added room to rotate a broad workpiece.
The ranking favors versatile, usable setups first, then models with a clearer advantage for a particular need. The DEWALT DW788 takes the lead for its 20-inch capacity and variable-speed approach; compactness, expanded throat reach, and convenience features earn other models distinct roles. Several saws share a 16-inch format, so I distinguish them by their listed features rather than treating similar capacity as proof of identical performance. Product details can vary by version, so buyers should verify the exact model and included accessories before ordering.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Woodworking Scroll Saws
Choosing between these saws is less about finding the longest feature list and more about matching the machine to the pieces you plan to cut. I’d start with the size and shape of your work, then weigh control and setup convenience against shop space and the extra tools you may already own.
Match throat capacity to your actual workpieces
Throat capacity describes how far the blade sits from the rear frame, giving a rough sense of how far a workpiece can extend to the side of the blade. A larger throat can make it easier to rotate wide panels or work on larger patterns, which is why the 18-, 20-, and 22-inch options deserve attention for bigger projects. For ornaments, small signs, and compact craft pieces, a 16-inch saw may be easier to accommodate without limiting the work you do. A common mistake is to choose the largest number available without checking whether the saw fits your bench and can support the material comfortably. Capacity also does not guarantee better cut quality; blade selection and steady feed matter just as much. Measure your typical projects and available bench space before paying for reach you rarely use.
Treat speed control as a material and control tool
Variable speed gives you a way to adapt the cutting pace to the work and your comfort level. Slower settings can help when learning to follow a tight pattern or when working with delicate stock, while faster settings may suit straightforward cuts when the blade and material allow it. Do not assume a higher motor rating alone tells you how controllable a saw will feel; the available speed range and the way the control is placed also affect use. Buyers who mainly cut one familiar material may not need to pay extra for features they rarely adjust. If your projects vary, prioritize a speed control that is easy to reach while keeping both hands focused on guiding the workpiece. Match the blade to the material rather than trying to compensate for an unsuitable blade with speed changes.
Check how blade changes fit your pattern work
Interior cutouts require removing and rethreading a blade through a drilled hole, so blade changes can interrupt a project many times over. Easy-access systems, such as those listed on the WEN 3922 and another WEN model in this roundup, may matter more to frequent pattern cutters than a small difference in throat size. Buyers should check which blade types the saw accepts and whether changing blades requires tools or awkward access around the frame. A quick-release feature is most useful when the project has many enclosed openings; it matters less for simple exterior outlines. Look at blade compatibility before buying because pinned and pinless blades suit different holders and cutting plans. Budget for suitable replacement blades as part of the setup, not as an afterthought.
Choose visibility and dust handling for your workspace
A work light or LED can help reveal a drawn line, especially when the saw sits in a dim corner or the pattern uses fine detail. Lighting placement matters: a lamp that casts shadows across the blade area may be less useful than a focused, adjustable source. Dust ports can help connect the saw to a collection setup, but a port alone does not promise a clean work surface; check its size and whether it matches your extractor or hose. If you work indoors, also plan for general dust collection and cleanup rather than relying on the saw feature by itself. Extra visibility and dust control are worthwhile for long sessions, but they should not outweigh blade access or capacity if those are your main needs. An external task light can sometimes solve a visibility problem without deciding the whole purchase around a built-in lamp.
Pay for extras only when they change your workflow
Foot switches, tilting tables, rotary shafts, and miter gauges can extend what a scroll saw setup does, but each adds complexity or takes up space. A foot switch may help a maker who wants hands free to guide delicate work, while a rotary shaft is relevant only if you plan to use that kind of accessory. A tilting table can support angled cuts, yet it is not a substitute for checking the table’s adjustment and locking method. Buyers often overvalue bundled features and undervalue a stable bench, clear lighting, and a supply of the right blades. Compare each extra with the task it will serve and leave it out of your decision if it will sit unused. This approach can favor a simpler saw that fits your projects over a more elaborate machine with accessories you do not need.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose a 16-inch scroll saw or pay for a larger throat?
I’d choose a 16-inch model if most of your work is small to medium-sized and your patterns do not require rotating broad panels around the blade. A larger throat, such as the 18-, 20-, or 22-inch options here, gives more room for wide pieces and can reduce the need to reposition or redesign a project. It does not make a saw more precise by itself, and the larger frame may take more bench space. Start with the dimensions of your usual work, not the occasional project you might try someday. If large panels are a regular part of your plans, extra reach is easier to justify.
Are easy blade changes worth prioritizing for a scroll saw?
They can be, especially if you cut patterns with many interior openings that require removing and reinstalling the blade. In that kind of work, repeated threading and tightening can slow the project and become a source of frustration. If you mostly cut simple outlines, blade access may matter less than capacity, speed control, or table stability. Check how the system works and whether it supports the blade style you intend to use; a feature label alone does not answer those questions. I’d give blade-change convenience a high priority for intricate fretwork and a moderate priority for occasional straightforward cuts.
Can the Dremel Moto-Saw replace a full-size woodworking scroll saw?
The Moto-Saw is a better fit for light-duty projects, small workpieces, and buyers who value a compact setup or easier storage. It does not offer the same work capacity as the full-size saws in this roundup, so it is a poor match if you regularly cut broad panels or want a dedicated bench machine for extended shop work. Think about the size and thickness of your normal projects before treating compactness as a complete substitute for capacity. For occasional craft work, its smaller format may be a useful advantage. For larger or more demanding work, a full-size model is the safer category to compare.
Do a work light and dust port make a major difference?
They can improve comfort and visibility, but neither feature replaces good shop lighting or a suitable dust-collection setup. A built-in LED or work light is most useful when it illuminates the blade and pattern without casting distracting shadows. A dust port is helpful only if it connects well to the hose or extractor you have available, and it may not capture all debris on its own. If your workspace is already bright and you have nearby dust collection, these features may be secondary. If you work in a compact indoor area, they deserve more weight in your decision.
Which features should a first-time scroll saw buyer prioritize?
I’d start with an easy-to-control variable speed, a clear view of the blade area, and a blade-change process you can manage without excessive setup. A 16-inch model is enough for many starter projects and is generally a more sensible starting point than paying for throat capacity you may not use. Check blade compatibility and read the setup instructions before buying, since the right blade and a stable bench affect the learning experience. Built-in lights can help, but they should not be the only source of illumination. Leave specialized extras for later unless you already know they match the work you want to do.
Conclusion
For the broadest mix of shop projects, I recommend the DEWALT DW788 as the best overall, thanks to its 20-inch capacity and variable-speed control. Buyers focused on value should compare the straightforward WEN 16-inch models and choose between a work light and easier blade access based on their cutting habits. For a premium, feature-rich setup, the Shop Fox W1872 stands apart with its foot switch, LED light, miter gauge, and rotary shaft, though those extras make the most sense when you will use them. Beginners may prefer a manageable 16-inch variable-speed saw with clear lighting, while occasional makers with limited storage should look at the Dremel Moto-Saw. If your work regularly involves larger panels, consider the 18- or 22-inch BUCKTOOL models; choose added reach only when your projects justify the bench space.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
